Table of Contents
Executive Summary
Introduction
The California State Legislature passed the Voter’s Choice Act (the Act) in 2016 (Senate Bill 450, Allen), which was intended to modernize elections in California by allowing counties to conduct all vote-by-mail elections and replace one-day polling places with regional Vote Centers open for up to 11 days. The Act was designed to increase voter participation and significantly change how elections are conducted through expanded access and voting options.
The Marin County Board of Supervisors approved resolution 2021-33 on May 25, 2021, confirming implementation of the California Voter’s Choice Act in Marin County, and authorizing the Registrar of Voters to perform all activities required to implement the Act starting with the June 2022 primary election.
The initial Election Administration Plan implementing the Act in Marin County was approved by the Secretary of State on October 29, 2021. Two years after implementation, a revised plan will be reviewed following the public process outlined in the Act. Elections Code §4005(a)(10)(G)
As required by the Act, the Elections Department has a Language Accessibility Advisory Committee (LAAC) and a Voting Accessibility Advisory Committee (VAAC). The committees meet quarterly with the Registrar of Voters to discuss issues and provide feedback about improving the voting experience.
Overview
Under the Voter’s Choice Act, all active registered voters are automatically mailed a vote-by-mail packet no later than 29 days before each election. If voters require in-person services such as registering to vote or updating voter registration, receiving a replacement vote-by-mail ballot, or voting on accessible voting equipment, they may visit any regional Vote Center. In addition, ballot drop boxes are available throughout the county beginning not less than 28 days before Election Day.
The number of Vote Centers and ballot drop boxes is determined by the number of registered voters on the 88th day before an election. Based on the current number of registered voters, Marin County is required to establish a minimum of 18 Vote Centers (four open 10 days before the election, and all 18 open three days before the election and on Election Day) and 12 ballot drop box sites open beginning not less than 28 days before the election and on Election Day until 8 p.m. Voters may return their ballot by U.S. mail, at a ballot drop box, or at any Vote Center.
Local special elections will have fewer Vote Centers and ballot drop boxes. The number of locations will depend on the number of registered voters within the jurisdiction. For example, if a jurisdiction has fewer than 30,000 registered voters, the elections official will make a reasonable effort to establish one Vote Center within the jurisdiction.
Vote Center locations are selected based on specific criteria, such as population centers, parking, access to public transportation, low rate of vote by mail usage, minority language communities, and proximity to low-income communities. Locations are also evaluated on size, availability, accessibility, computer connectivity and security.
Return to top
Vote By Mail (VBM)
Elections Code §4005(a)(8)(A-B); §4005(a)(10)(I)(ii)
County Voter Information Guide
The Voter Information Guide (VIG) the Elections Department prepares for each election includes detailed information on the vote-by-mail process, options for requesting a replacement vote-by-mail ballot (VBM ballot), and options for returning a VBM ballot. The VIG also includes locations and hours of operation of drop boxes and Vote Centers.
Receiving A VBM Ballot
No later than 29 days before each election, all Marin County active registered voters are mailed a VBM ballot packet. The ballot packet includes instructions and a postage-paid return ballot envelope.
Requesting A Remote Accessible Ballot
Marin County registered voters may opt to go on-line, through the Remote Accessible Vote By Mail (RAVBM) system, to request a downloadable ballot.
The RAVBM system allows voters to access and mark an electronic version of their ballot on their own device, such as a personal computer. Because they are using their own device, they also can use their own assistive technology, such as a screen reader, to navigate and mark their ballot. Once a voter marks the ballot using the RAVBM system, the voter must print the ballot on paper and return the printed ballot to elections officials using the same return methods that apply to paper vote-by-mail ballots.
Requesting A Replacement Ballot
Any voter may request a replacement ballot by visiting any Vote Center, including the Elections Department, or completing and returning the required form. Voters may have a representative pick-up a replacement ballot by having the representative bring the required form in person to the Elections Department. For more information, voters may call (415) 473-6456, or toll free, (833) 644-2061. Voters with communication disabilities may call 711 (CA Relay Service).
Return to top
Vote Centers
Elections Code §4005(a)(3)(A); §4005(a)(4)(A,C-E); §4005(a)(6)(B-D) §4005(a)(10)(I)(ii); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(I); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(III), §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(VI); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(IX); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(X); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(XI)
Number of Vote Centers and Hours of Operation
The number of Vote Centers and hours of operation are established in the Elections Code. Beginning 10 days before an election for a minimum of eight hours per day, at least one Vote Center is provided for every 50,000 registered voters. Three days before an election, for a minimum of eight hours per day and from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. on Election Day, at least one Vote Center is provided for every 10,000 registered voters.
The number of Vote Centers is determined by the number of registered voters on the 88th day before an election. Based on the current number of registered voters, the Elections Department is required to establish at least 18 Vote Centers—four open for 10 days prior to and on Election Day, and an additional fourteen open for three days prior to and on Election Day.
Local special elections will have fewer Vote Centers and ballot drop boxes. The number of locations will depend on the number of registered voters within the jurisdiction. For example, if a jurisdiction has fewer than 30,000 registered voters, the elections official will make a reasonable effort to establish one Vote Center within the jurisdiction.
Locations
History
To establish the Vote Center locations in 2022, county staff created data maps for criteria listed in Elections Code section §4005(a)(10)(B)(i-xv) using data collected from the 2010 decennial Census, the American Community Survey, and the voter registration file current at that time. The data maps showed the areas of highest number of overlapping criteria and were used to evaluate potential locations; the criteria map review complemented a functional assessment of size, availability, security, internet connectivity, and accessibility. In addition, the Elections Department evaluated prior locations of polling places to determine suitability for Vote Centers, See Appendix A for criteria The Elections Department worked with the Language Accessibility Advisory Committee (LAAC), Voting Accessibility Advisory Committee (VAAC), and community members via community consultation sessions to identify Vote Center locations that were considered trusted, familiar sites.
Current Sites
The Elections Department established 20 Vote Centers that were used in the June and November 2022 elections. The list of locations and hours of operation were posted on the Department’s website for each election (www.marinvotes.org) and were included in election materials provided to each registered voter. These sites will continue to be used for future elections and the information will be posted online and printed in the Voter Information Guide. See Appendix B and Appendix E for more information.
Staffing and Language Assistance
The Department hires two Vote Center coordinators and at least three election workers for each location, including bilingual staff. The Vote Center coordinators are hired through the county’s employee recruitment process and the election workers are hired from a pool of prior poll workers. Vote Center coordinators manage the sites and return voted ballots after Vote Centers close for the day. This staffing model will continue into the future.
The Secretary of State’s office provides the list of languages in addition to English that are required in the jurisdiction. Specified election materials are translated into the jurisdiction’s required languages. Currently, Marin County’s required languages, other than English, are Chinese, Spanish and Vietnamese. The Department will continue to recruit prior bilingual poll workers and collaborate with the LAAC to identify potential new sources of bilingual staff.
Voter Services
At any Vote Center, voters are able to: 1) Return, or vote and return, their vote-by-mail ballot; 2) register to vote, or update their registration, and vote; 3) receive and vote a provisional ballot; 4) receive a replacement vote-by-mail ballot; 5) vote a regular, provisional, or replacement ballot using accessible voting equipment.
Accessible Ballot and Aides for Voters with Disabilities
An accessible ballot marking device (BMD) manufactured by Dominion Voting Systems is available for use by all Marin County registered voters at any Vote Center. A minimum of three devices is required at each location. The BMD is activated with a key card that populates the device with the voter’s specific ballot. The ballot can be marked using the touchscreen display, an audio tactile device, or a voter’s own assistive technology. The accessible voting machines will be arranged to allow all voters the opportunity to cast their ballot privately and independently. These devices are certified by the Secretary of State for use in California elections. BMD equipment is not connected to the Election Information Management System, the central vote tabulating system located at the Elections Department, or the internet.
The Department will continue providing valuable services previously offered at traditional polling places. Vote Centers will provide accessible voting booths, magnifiers, pens with easy-to-hold grips, and signature guides. Mitigation equipment will be provided to Vote Center locations as needed, such as threshold ramps, door stops, or cones to designate accessible parking.
Curbside voting will be available for voters unable to physically go into the Vote Center. Voters may call the number listed on the Vote Here sign, or they may use the outside call bell, which will alert Vote Center workers that someone needs assistance.
Like traditional poll workers before them, staff at all Vote Centers receive training on assisting voters with specific needs and the use of the accessible ballot marking devices. Training materials were developed with input from the Voting Accessibility Advisory Committee.
Equipment
The accessible ballot marking device (BMD) at the Vote Center allows any voter to vote a regular, provisional, or replacement ballot, and features equipment that allows voters with visual, hearing, or physical disabilities to cast their ballot privately and independently. In addition, Vote Centers include:
- Laptop computers at check-in stations so workers can securely access a voter’s record to verify registration and to verify that voting has not already taken place.
- Ballot printing equipment so a voter may get a replacement vote-by-mail ballot, or precinct ballot.
- Laptop computers available as a voter index pursuant to Elections Code sections 14294 and 14298(c).
The above-listed equipment is stand-alone and is not connected to any unrelated components including the central vote tabulating system located at the Election Department. The voting system equipment (BMDs and ballot printing equipment) is not connected to the internet. Check-in and index laptop computers access voter registration information through a secure VPN in compliance with security measures determined by the County’s Information Services Technology staff.
Voters deposit their voted ballot into a locked ballot box. Ballots are reconciled daily and returned to the Elections Department for storage in a secure, alarmed area.
Design and Layout of Vote Centers
Layout guidelines are used to ensure voting booths and accessible ballot marking devices are placed in a manner that allows a voter to mark their ballot independently and privately. Layouts are accessible to voters with disabilities and will be adjusted to accommodate the varying shapes and room sizes of each location. See Appendix D for sample layout.
Return to top
Ballot Drop Boxes
Elections Code §4005(a)(1)(A-B); §4005(a)(10)(B); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(II)
Number of Ballot Drop Boxes and Hours of Operation
The number of ballot drop boxes and hours of operation are established in the Elections Code. At least one ballot drop box location is provided for every 15,000 registered voters within the jurisdiction. All locations shall be open at least during regular business hours beginning not less than 28 days before the election. At least one ballot drop box shall be an accessible, secured, exterior drop box that is available for a minimum of 12 hours per day including regular business hours.
Starting in 2022, the Elections Department established 12 ballot drop boxes open during regular business hours beginning 28 days before Election Day. At least two drop boxes are available 24/7 at the Civic Center, 3501 Civic Center Drive, San Rafael; one of which is a drive-thru location.
Locations
History
To establish the drop box locations in 2022, county staff created data maps for criteria listed in Elections Code section §4005(a)(10)(B) using data collected from the 2010 decennial Census, the American Community Survey, and the voter registration file current at that time. The data maps showed the areas of highest number of overlapping criteria and were used to assist with determining best locations; the criteria map review complemented a functional assessment of availability, security, and accessibility. See Appendix A for criteria.
The Elections Department worked with the Language Accessibility Advisory Committee (LAAC), Voting Accessibility Advisory Committee (VAAC), and community members via community consultation sessions to identify drop box locations that were considered trusted, familiar sites.
Current Sites
The Elections Department established 12 drop box sites that were used in the June and November 2022 elections. The list of locations and hours of operation were posted on the Department’s website for each election (www.marinvotes.org) and were included in election materials provided to each registered voter. These sites will continue to be used for future elections and the information will be posted online and printed in the Voter Information Guide. See Appendix C and Appendix E for more information.
Return to top
Voting Technology
Each Vote Center is equipped with three ballot marking devices (BMDs) on which voters can vote a regular, provisional, or replacement ballot. These units consist of a monitor and printer. The monitor is a touchscreen on which the voter makes selections and when finished, the voter prints their selections and deposits the ballot into a secure ballot box. The BMD is activated with a key card that remains in the possession of the Vote Center coordinator.
In addition, Vote Centers include laptop computers at check-in stations so workers can securely access a voter’s record to verify registration and to verify that voting has not already taken place. Laptops are connected to the election management system’s server, allowing it to generate a voter-specific label to be affixed to a log signed by the voter, thus creating a record of in-person voters. Check-in and index computer stations operate in full compliance with all security measures determined by the County’s Information Services Technology staff.
Vote Centers have ballot printing equipment to provide voters a replacement vote-by-mail or precinct ballot. Ballot printing equipment consists of a specialized laptop computer and printer. Staff are required to complete security logs to keep track of the ballots printed.
Voters deposit their voted ballot into a locked ballot box. Ballots are reconciled daily and returned to the Elections Department for storage in a secure, alarmed area until counted. All ballots are counted in the Elections Department on equipment that is located in a secure, alarmed room.
At the end of each day, the laptop computers that provide access to all Vote Center functions are placed in a locked cabinet. A tamper-evident security seal is placed in a manner to ensure the cabinet door remains secured; the security seal identification number is recorded on a log sheet.
Voting machines and ballot counting equipment are not connected to the internet.
Any voter, including voters in the military or residing overseas and voters with disabilities, may opt to go on-line, through the Remote Accessible Vote By Mail (RAVBM) system, to request a downloadable ballot. RAVBM offers the opportunity for voters to request an electronic VBM ballot accessible through an authorized website. The electronic ballot can be downloaded to the voter's computer, marked electronically and then printed. Instructions include a return envelope image so the ballot can be returned in the same manner as any VBM ballot: through the U.S. mail, placed in a ballot drop box, or hand-delivered to any Vote Center.
All election equipment goes through an extensive Logic & Accuracy Test to ensure each piece of equipment is in proper working order. The Logic & Accuracy Test is designed to provide an overview of the vote counting process and to verify that the ballot counting program prepared for the election is properly reading and tabulating votes.
Return to top
Security
Vote Centers
§4005(a)(4)(E)(ii); §4005(a)(10)(I)(iv)
All voting conducted at Vote Centers follows the Secretary of State's security standards, Elections Department security procedures, and regulations in the California Elections Code and the California Voting System Use Procedures. This includes, but is not limited to, ensuring all equipment at the Vote Center is sealed, stored, delivered, and used in compliance with these regulations. In addition, current procedures require the majority of the election workers to be present when the site is open.
All equipment used at Vote Centers requires Vote Center workers (VC workers) to log in using unique passwords. Voting system equipment is stand-alone and not connected to any unrelated components or the internet.
The Ballot Marking Device (BMD) is activated with a key card that remains in the possession of the Vote Center Coordinator. Laptop computers used to access voter registration information connect with the database using secure VPN wireless technology following the standards established by the County’s Information Services Technology Department. Those wishing to use the designated laptops to access the voter index are instructed to ask a Vote Center worker for assistance pursuant to Elections Code section 14298(c). The voter index laptop only allows access to the records defined in Elections Code section 14294.
Staff are required to complete security logs to keep track of the ballots printed on the specialized ballot printing equipment.
Ballots voted at the Vote Center are deposited into a locked drop box. Ballots are reconciled at the end of each day and returned by two election workers to the Elections Department for storage in a secure, alarmed area.
Any and all recorded votes, including paper ballots, ballots submitted on voting equipment, conditional voter registration (CVR) ballots, provisional ballots, and vote by mail ballots, are securely transported to the Marin County Elections Department following chain-of-custody requirements.
At the end of each day, the laptop computers that provide access to all Vote Center functions are placed in a locked cabinet. A tamper-evident security seal is placed in a manner to ensure the cabinet door remains secured; the security seal identification number is recorded on a log sheet.
Contingency Planning
§4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(VIII)(ia); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(VIII)(ib)
All staff, including lead staff working at the Vote Centers and those providing technical support, attend extensive training on the operation of the voting equipment, setting up a Vote Center, assisting and processing voters, securing sensitive equipment each voting night, and the proper procedures in case of an emergency.
Under California voting system requirements, all certified equipment must run on battery power in the event of a power outage. All locations have a cell phone. Emergency responders receive a list of all Vote Center locations. Each Vote Center is provided with emergency procedures and an instruction manual for the operation of a Vote Center and processing voters.
The Elections Department works to immediately resolve the disruption at a Vote Center, and each disruption will have its own response. Generally, if a single Vote Center is disrupted, the Elections Department will ask VC workers to direct voters to other Vote Centers and will inform local police, the Secretary of State’s office, and provide media updates to ensure voters are informed. If a natural disaster or other disturbance occurs that affects a Vote Center or ballot drop-off site’s physical location, additional notifications, signage, and staff will be available to direct voters to an alternate location. Should all activities at a Vote Center cease, staff will immediately secure that Vote Center's voting equipment and account for all voting materials in accordance with California Election Code and the Ballot Manufacturing and Finishing guidelines. The Elections Department will attempt to open a replacement Vote Center and extensively notice the change.
Return to top
Budget
Costs and Savings
§4005(a)(10)(I)(v)
The Registrar of Voters’ 2022 implementation of the Voter's Choice Act resulted in one-time costs to purchase ballot printing equipment and miscellaneous supplies, redesign VC worker training, and significantly expand requirements for community and voter engagement. The Registrar of Voters anticipates that ongoing costs to operate Vote Centers will be increasingly offset by reduced costs for operations that are no longer required. Updated estimates will be made available on the Elections Department’s website when such costs are known.
Return to top
Voter Education and Outreach Plan
General Requirements
The Marin County Elections Department uses the County Voter Information Guide, press releases, direct mail, and its own website to provide voters with the information needed to successfully cast a ballot. These traditional activities are supplemented by other outreach and education strategies to form the Voter Education and Outreach Plan that educates voters on important topics including options to register to vote and cast a ballot (i.e., by mail or in-person), a list of addresses and schedules of voting locations and ballot drop boxes, instructions for obtaining a replacement or a translated facsimile copy of a ballot, or options for receiving and voting a HAVA-compliant accessible ballot. (HAVA—Help America Vote Act )
Prior to implementing the Voter’s Choice Act (VCA), the Elections Department engaged a network of civic, governmental, faith-based, educational, and community-based/service delivery organizations committed to a common mission: increasing civic participation. Initially dubbed the Outreach Partner Network, this collective of diverse partners directly participated in outreach and education through a variety of methods including displaying posters and flyers, publishing messages via social media, email, newsletters, and contacting voters directly. To coincide with implementation of VCA, the Elections Department wished to acknowledge the contributions of the network’s member organizations and recognize the community’s commitment to voter education and civic participation. Thus, in 2022, the Elections Department converted the network into a formal advisory group: the Voter Education and Outreach Advisory Committee (VEOAC).
The VEOAC will be instrumental in identifying emerging community trends in order to design needs-responsive outreach and education strategies. The organizations listed below are currently part of the VEOAC. The Elections Department utilizes the VEOAC during an election cycle to review and disseminate messaging as outlined in the following sections.
Voter Education and Outreach Advisory Committee (VEOAC)
| Agricultural Institute of Marin |
Libraries – San Anselmo Library |
| Asian Advocacy Project |
Mainstreet Moms |
| Bayside MLK Academy |
Marin Center for Independent Living |
| Board of Supervisors Aides |
Marin Community Clinics |
| Canal Alliance |
Marin County Commission on Aging |
| Clerk, City of Belvedere |
Marin Co. Comm Development Agency |
| Clerk, Town of Corte Madera |
Marin Co. Disability Access Program |
| Clerk, Town of Fairfax |
Marin County Equity Director |
| Clerk, City of Larkspur |
Marin County Youth Commission |
| Clerk, City of Mill Valley |
Marin Interfaith Council |
| Clerk, City of Novato |
Multicultural Center of Marin |
| Clerk, Town of Ross |
North Marin Community Services |
| Clerk, Town of San Anselmo |
Party Central Committee Democratic |
| Clerk, City of San Rafael |
Party Central Committee Peace & Freedom |
| Clerk, City of Sausalito |
Party Central Committee Republican |
| Clerk, Town of Tiburon |
Performing Stars |
| Community Action Marin |
Play Marin |
| Elections Dept. Election Advisory Comm. |
Student Elections Ambassador Program |
| Elections Dept. LAAC |
The Spahr Center |
| Elections Dept. VAAC |
Veda Florez (individual contractor) |
| Hearing Loss Assoc.of America (North Bay) |
Vivalon |
| Homeward Bound |
West Marin Community Services |
| League of Women Voters |
West Marin Multi-Services Ctr, Co. HHS |
| Libraries – Belvedere Tiburon Library |
West Marin Senior Services |
Media/Public Service Announcements
§4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(I); §4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(II); §4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(VIII)
The Elections Department has access to a variety of media outlets to alert voters of upcoming elections, provide important voting information (including voter registration eligibility, expected arrival of vote by mail ballot, and obtaining a ballot in an accessible format), and promote the Elections Department’s toll-free voter assistance hotline (833- 644-2061) and 711 (CA Relay Service). The Elections Department produces a free Outreach Kit that is disseminated to the VEOAC and other interested community groups or members. Recipients are able to select from contents that may include posters, flyers, print-ready newsletter stories, and prepared messages that mirror the election cycle and are tailored to each media format. The aforementioned voter information is incorporated into the contents of the kit. For prepared text, social media, or email messaging, a “go live schedule” for releasing those messages is included. The Elections Department uses a mix of press releases, public notices on its website, and its own social media (Facebook) to increase voter awareness of significant events or deadlines.
Marin County is served mainly by regional (Bay Area) network television media located in San Francisco, Oakland, and San José. While Marin County voters may benefit from outreach in the greater bay area, the Elections Department will mitigate this limitation by relying on its VEOAC and access to local print media (e.g., Marin Independent Journal, Pt Reyes Light, Pacific Sun), targeted digital advertising (e.g., Hearst Media), or cable access television networks (e.g., Community Media Center of Marin) to ensure Marin County voters receive locally relevant information including notifying voters of an upcoming election and promoting the toll-free voter assistance hotline. In addition, local newspapers or radio stations serving language minority communities may be used when the Elections Department needs to provide those communities with the same information but translated or interpreted for bilingual or monolingual voters.
Each incorporated city and town in Marin County is a VEOAC partner and has web pages dedicated to elections that are used to keep residents updated about their local elections.
The Elections Department is able to produce a public service announcement (PSA) utilizing newspapers, radio, or television formats that alerts voters of the upcoming election and important voting information including voter registration eligibility, expected arrival of a vote by mail ballot, Vote Center or ballot drop box location information, promotion of the Elections Department’s toll-free voter assistance hotline, and instructions for obtaining a ballot in an accessible format. PSAs can be translated into required languages per federal and state election law and disseminated via newspapers, radio, or television formats that target each of those language minority communities.
Community Presence
§4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(III)
From its initial diverse Outreach Partners network, the Elections Department recruited founding members of its Language Accessibility Advisory Committee (LAAC). The LAAC, along with the Elections Department’s Voter Accessibility Advisory Committee (VAAC), Election Advisory Committee (EAC), and Voter Education and Outreach Advisory Committee (VEOAC) form an invaluable network. The reciprocal sharing of information, experience, and advice informs Elections Department staff of community trends and preferences while fulfilling committee members’ mission to encourage and promote civic participation. In addition to maintaining multiple advisory committees, the Elections Department will use a variety of strategies to remain visible and maintain a community presence, such as conducting “educational workshops” at existing community events and known public gathering spots, accepting invitations for speaking engagements, submitting Op Ed or other educational articles to local newspapers, and conducting targeted outreach to historically underrepresented communities. To increase visibility, the Elections Department may supplement efforts with paid advertising (e.g., on buses, in local publications, or on social media) or offer contracts to community partners to fund specific activities such as neighborhood “door-to-door” campaigns, disseminating door hangers, or producing videos that promote civic engagement. The Elections Department’s use of static displays such as posters or banners throughout the county maximizes exposure to eligible and registered voters. Posters and banners are effective in promoting voter registration and alerting voters of upcoming elections. Based on community feedback, the Elections Department consistently utilizes “plain language” principles with brief and concise language to ensure effective messaging.
Voter Services
§4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(X); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(IX); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(X); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vi)(XI); §4005(a)(10)(I)(vii); §4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(IV); §4005(a)(10)(J)
The Elections Department provides services that benefit all voters while also targeting education and outreach to historically underrepresented voters. All active, registered voters receive two direct notices by mail announcing the name and date of the upcoming election and promoting the toll-free voter assistance hotline.
The first mailer will be sent far enough in advance to allow undeliverable mail to be returned to the Department so that we may update the voter’s mailing address and our mailing list for voters. This mailer will emphasize 1) registration; 2) election preparedness; and 3) other information appropriate for messaging early in the voting cycle.
The second mailer will be sent in the weeks prior to Election Day and will be more detail orientated with information needed to participate, such as 1) when to expect to receive a vote by mail ballot; 2) location and operating hours of Vote Centers; 3) Drop Box locations; 4) deadline reminders; 5) promotion of early voting; 6) contact information; 7) certification timeline; and 8) instructions for obtaining a RAVBM ballot or translated facsimile ballot.
Both mailers will include translations or instructions to access translations online to ensure language minority voters can access the same information. Voters with additional questions are encouraged to visit the Elections Department’s accessible website (which may be viewed with Google translate) to find the nearest Vote Center and drop box locations, read the County Voter Information Guide, or learn how to request a facsimile or accessible ballot. Voters may also call the Elections Department’s toll-free voter assistance hotline or 711 (CA Relay for voters with disabilities) to speak with a live person.
Vote Center layout guidelines will be used to ensure voting booths and accessible ballot marking devices are placed in a manner that allows a voter to mark their ballot independently and privately. Layouts will be sensitive to the accessibility needs of voters and will be adjusted to accommodate the varying shapes and room sizes of each location. Informational and directional signage and literature required by the Voter’s Choice Act and/or the California Secretary of State’s Office will be conspicuously displayed.
The Voter Education and Outreach Plan will be available in an accessible format on the Elections Department’s website; it will be in English and translated into each required language according to federal and state election law.
Budget
§4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(VII)
The Elections Department will spend the necessary resources to ensure voters are informed of the voting process under the Voter’s Choice Act and how to be ready to participate in upcoming elections. In addition to using various media, community presence, and advisory committees to distribute information, all active, registered voters receive two direct notices by mail from the Elections Department as specified above.
A comparison of anticipated Voter Education and Outreach Plan expenses with prior outreach budgets is shown in Appendix F.
Targeted Outreach: Language Minority Communities
The Elections Department is committed to providing effective voter education and outreach to language minority communities that includes translations of required information and instructions, notice of language services available at Vote Centers, or postage-paid return postcards for requesting a translated facsimile vote by mail ballot in an eligible language other than English. In addition, the Elections Department will collaborate with the LAAC and VEOAC to develop culturally and linguistically appropriate educational materials for language minority communities.
Identifying Communities
§4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(V)
The Elections Department will use a variety of sources to identify communities that may require language services including those identified by the California Secretary of State pursuant to Elections Code §14201, using census data and mapping technology to locate geographically concentrated voters with limited-English proficiency, and surveying its three advisory committees for insights. The LAAC will be queried for their expertise regarding unique language or regional differences that may impact outreach efforts such as selection of trusted sources for sharing information (e.g., preferred radio, newspapers, or social medial platforms).
Bilingual Communications and Public Input
§4005(a)(10)(G); §4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(VI)(ia); §4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(IX)
The Elections Department will accept public comments for 14 days on draft revisions to the Outreach and Education Plan herein (as part of a two-year review of the initial Election Administration Plan). The public comment period precedes a public meeting at which the Elections Department considers additional public comment before finalizing amendments to the plan. If the draft plan is amended after the public meeting, there will be an additional 14-day public comment period before adopting a final plan.
The Department’s advisory committees will have an opportunity to review the revised plan prior to the public process.
For the two-year (and subsequent four-year) required revision to the Election Administration Plan (EAP), the Elections Department will use the public input process described above to seek feedback from language minority communities for each of the county’s federal and state required languages.
The Elections Department will consult with the LAAC and VEOAC to determine the most effective, needs-responsive strategies for delivering voter education within language minority communities. These bilingual “educational workshops” may employ a variety of formats and forums (e.g., during existing community events or located in known public gathering spots) and will focus on increasing awareness of voting eligibility and educating voters about their voting options under the Voter’s Choice Act. The workshops will describe services offered at Vote Centers, including the availability of translated facsimile ballots to aid in voting on the official ballot and the availability of other translated materials such as state voter information guides. Announcements for bilingual events will be disseminated via the Elections Department’s advisory groups, website, and media (including social media, press releases). The Elections Department will solicit feedback from the LAAC and VEOAC as well as examine data provided by the California Secretary of State that suggest practices that may improve voter attendance and participation at outreach events targeting language minority communities.
Workshops may be held 90 days before an election and up to the final day of voting as opportunities to interact with voters arise or are created. A minimum of one workshop will be held for each federal election or special state election, and workshops will be held for local elections as those communities deem necessary.
In order to be both cost-effective and efficient in conducting outreach, the Elections Department may amend or reuse existing translated public service announcement (PSA) materials and utilize the most appropriate print, television, or radio media to target language minority communities. PSAs will alert voters of the upcoming election and important voting information such as when to expect to receive a vote by mail ballot, how to locate a Vote Center or ballot drop box, or instructions for accessing the Elections Department’s toll-free voter assistance hotline. Currently, Marin County’s required languages, other than English, are Spanish, Chinese, and Vietnamese. The Elections Department will accommodate language changes to voter education and outreach activities as needed.
Targeted Outreach: Voters With Disabilities
Accessible Communications and Public Input
§4005(a)(10)(G); §4005(a)(10)(I)(i)(VI)(ib); §4005(a)(10)(I)(iii)
The Elections Department will accept public comments for 14 days on draft revisions to the Outreach and Education Plan herein (as part of a two-year review of the initial Election Administration Plan). The public comment period precedes a public meeting at which the Elections Department considers additional public comment before finalizing amendments to the plan. If the draft plan is amended after the public meeting, there will be an additional 14-day public comment period before adopting a final plan.
The Department’s advisory committees will have an opportunity to review the revised plan prior to the public process.
For this two-year (and subsequent four-year) required revision to the Election Administration Plan (EAP), the Elections Department will use the public input process described above to seek feedback from the disability community.
The Elections Department will consult with the VAAC and VEOAC to determine the most effective, needs-responsive strategies for delivering voter education within the disability community. These “educational workshops” may employ a variety of formats and forums (e.g. during existing community events or located in known public gathering spots), and will focus on increasing awareness of voting eligibility and educating voters about their voting options under the Voter’s Choice Act. The workshops will describe services offered, such as, the toll-free voter assistance hotline and accessible voting--i.e., how to request and cast a remote-accessible ballot or how to vote in person with a ballot marking device that allows visually- or hearing-impaired voters to vote privately and independently.
The Elections Department will seek assistance from sign language interpreters and Communication Access Realtime Translation (CART) captioners to facilitate communication with attendees. Announcements for accessibility-focused events will be disseminated via the Elections Department’s advisory groups, accessible website, and media (including social media, press releases). The Elections Department will solicit feedback from the VAAC and VEOAC as well as examine data provided by the California Secretary of State that suggest practices that may improve voter attendance and participation at outreach events targeting the disability community.
Workshops may be held 90 days before an election and up to the final day of voting as opportunities to interact with voters arise or are created. A minimum of one workshop will be held for each federal election or special state election, and workshops will be held for local elections as those communities deem necessary.
In order to be both cost-effective and efficient in conducting outreach, the Elections Department may amend or reuse existing accessible public service announcement (PSA) materials and utilize the most appropriate print, television, or radio media to target the disability community. PSAs will alert voters of the upcoming election and important voting information such as when to expect to receive a vote by mail ballot, how to locate a Vote Center or ballot drop box, promoting the Elections Department’s toll-free voter assistance hotline, and how to obtain a ballot in an accessible format.
Return to top
List of Appendices
Appendix A – Criteria for Vote Center and ballot drop box locations
§4005(a)(10)(B)
The county elections official considered the following criteria outlined in the Elections Code when establishing Vote Center and drop box locations in 2022:
- Proximity to:
- Public transportation
- Communities with historically low vote by mail usage
- Population centers
- Language minority communities
- Voters with disabilities
- Communities with low rates of household vehicle ownership
- Low-income communities
- Communities of eligible voters who are not registered to vote and may need access to same day voter registration
- Geographically isolated populations, including Native American reservations
- Accessible and free parking
- The distance and time a voter must travel by car or public transportation
- The need for alternate methods for voters with disabilities for whom vote by mail ballots are not accessible to cast a ballot
- Traffic patterns
- The need for mobile Vote Centers in addition to the number of Vote Centers established pursuant to this section
- Vote Center locations on a public or private university or college campus
The Elections Department will continue using locations that were established in 2022 and will make adjustments if needed.
Appendix B — Vote Center locations
Elections Department staff rely on their experience, knowledge, and fifteen factors set forth in the Elections Code to identify ideal locations based on their incidence of factors including proximity to historically low vote by mail usage, language minority communities, population centers, or voters with disabilities, as well as historical use as a polling place, geographic distribution, and physical capacity of the location.
The list of locations established in 2022 can be found at www.marinvotes.org by clicking on the link to past elections, and then selecting either the June or November 2022 election; a map is also available.
The Elections Department will continue using locations that were established in 2022 and will make adjustments if needed.
Appendix C — Drop box locations
Elections Department staff rely on their experience, knowledge, and fifteen factors set forth in the Elections Code to identify ideal locations based on their incidence of factors including proximity to historically low vote by mail usage, language minority communities, population centers, or voters with disabilities, as well as historical use as a ballot drop box or drop off location, geographic distribution, and physical accessibility and security of the location.
The list of locations established in 2022 can be found at www.marinvotes.org by clicking on the link to past elections, and then selecting either the June or November 2022 election; a map is also available. Additional locations will be considered based on need.
The Elections Department will continue using locations that were established in 2022 and will make adjustments if needed.
Appendix D — Vote Center sample design and layout
Example Vote Center Set-Up
(Voters may choose paper ballot or ballot marking device)
KEY
| BMD |
Accessible Ballot Marking Device |
| CVR |
Conditional Voter Registration |
| MBP |
Mobile Ballot Printing |
| VBM |
Vote-by-Mail |
Appendix E — Website Information
Detailed information about the Marin County Elections Department may be accessed at www.marinvotes.org. Voters will find information about:
- Locations and hours of operation of Voter Centers and drop boxes
- Accessible voting (remote accessible vote by mail)
- Requesting a translated sample ballot
- General election information
- Observer opportunities
- Translated outreach information
- Voter registration
Appendix F — Voter education and outreach budget in 2022 and anticipated in 2024
June 2022 Primary Election
| Election-related Activities |
Budget |
| Outreach Consultant |
$5,250 |
| League of Women Voters |
$2,500 |
| Direct Mailings 2x |
$92,284.29 |
| Banners |
$5,850 |
| Posters |
$1,212.60 |
| Factsheets |
$1,760 |
| Newsletters |
$480 |
| Rack Cards |
$6,750 |
| Taxes on Printed Materials |
$1,484.87 |
| Outreach Toolkit Stock Images |
$48 |
| Outreach Toolkit (translations) |
$3,828.42 |
| Print Media |
$10,607.26 |
| Digital Media |
$6,550 |
| Workshops (translators) |
$1,366.10 |
| Workshop PPT (translations) |
$1,211.47 |
| Grand Total |
$141,183.01 |
November 2022 General Election
| Election-related Activities |
Budget |
| Outreach Consultant |
$5,250 |
| League of Women Voters |
$2,500 |
| Direct Mailings 2x |
$98,891.89 |
| Banners |
$91.14 |
| Posters |
$1,368 |
| Factsheets |
$1,620 |
| Newsletters |
$540 |
| Rack Cards |
$5,400 |
| Taxes on Printed Materials |
$831.78 |
| Bus Ads |
$5,775 |
| Outreach Toolkit (translations) |
$4,900.92 |
| Print Media |
$8,048.26 |
| Digital Media |
$5,000 |
| Workshops (translators) |
$485.12 |
| Workshop PPT (translations) |
$349 |
| Grand Total |
$141,051.11 |
Outreach Budget Anticipated for 2024
| Election-related Activities |
Budget |
| Outreach Consultant |
$5,250 |
| League of Women Voters |
$2,500 |
| Direct Mailings 2x |
$100,000 |
| Banners |
$6,000 |
| Posters |
$1,300 |
| Factsheets |
$1,800 |
| Newsletters |
$500 |
| Rack Cards |
$7,000 |
| Taxes on Printed Materials |
$1,500 |
| Bus Ads |
$6,000 |
| Outreach Toolkit (translations) |
$4,000 |
| Print Media |
$10,700 |
| Digital Media |
$7,000 |
| Workshops (translators) |
$1,500 |
| Workshop PPT (translations) |
$1,500 |
| Grand Total |
$156,550 |